| New York NYY | | | | Nestor Cortes vs Michael Wacha | |
| Miami MIA | | | | Jordan Holloway vs Jorge Lopez | |
| Milwaukee MIL | | | | Eric Lauer vs Onbeslist | |
| Washington WSH | | | | Patrick Corbin vs Zack Wheeler | |
| Atlanta ATL | | | | Max Fried vs Tylor Megill | |
| Toronto TOR | | | | Steven Matz vs Tanner Houck | |
| Arizona ARI | | | | Madison Bumgarner vs Jordan Lyles | |
| Cincinnati CIN | | | | Tyler Mahle vs Zach Davies | |
| Chicago CHW | | | | Lucas Giolito vs Kris Bubic | |
| Colorado COL | | | | Chi Chi Gonzalez vs Andrew Heaney | |
| Los Angeles LAD | | | | Walker Buehler vs Anthony DeSclafani | |
| Atlanta ATL | | | | Drew Smyly vs Taijuan Walker | |
| Washington WSH | | | | Jon Lester vs Vince Velasquez | |
| New York NYY | | | | Gerrit Cole vs Luis Patino | |
| Chicago CHW | | | | Carlos Rodon vs Carlos Hernandez | |
| Cincinnati CIN | | | | Luis Castillo vs Alec Mills | |
| Los Angeles LAD | | | | David Price vs Johnny Cueto | |
